Best Key Lime Pie For Your Key West Elopement

The Best Key Lime Pie in Key West: Elopement Dessert Inspiration

If you’re planning an elopement in Key West, you’re definitely in the market to find the best key lime pie. But let’s be real – no trip to Key West (or marriage for that matter) is complete without indulging in its most iconic dessert: key lime pie. And if you’re looking for wedding cake alternatives or unique Florida elopement desserts, this tangy treat might just steal the show.

As a Key West elopement photographer, I’ve explored every corner of this island capturing unforgettable love stories—and yes, I’ve done my fair share of pie tasting along the way. Keep in mind that almost every restaurant in the Florida Keys has a key lime pie option so you really can’t go wrong anywhere – these just happen to be my favorites! Whether you’re dreaming of a laid-back beach picnic, a wild bar crawl along Duval, or romantic dinner on the water, I’ve got the inside scoop on the best spots in the Keys. Let’s dive in!

My Top Key Lime Pie Picks in Key West

1. Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe (Key West) – Rating: 9/10

Kermit’s Key Lime Shoppe is the gold standard for traditional key lime pie, and for good reason. The graham cracker crust strikes the perfect balance with the tart, sweet custard filling. It’s simple, classic, and absolutely delicious. Their service is fast, and if you or your partner aren’t into pie, they offer tons of other key lime-inspired treats (think cookies, chocolates, and even key lime wine).

This spot is amazing for Key West elopements since it’s conveniently located near Duval Street and they offer to go slices. You could even grab one of their mini pies to cut as a “cake” moment or grab some key lime flavored treats for your family back home.

2. Louie’s Backyard (Key West) – Rating: 8/10

Louie’s Backyard adds a unique twist with a chocolate ginger snap crust instead of the traditional graham cracker. The custard is super light and fluffy, and the presentation feels upscale—perfect for couples who want a little extra flair.

While you can get this treat to go, this pie is best served for dining in. Louie’s Backyard has a romantic waterfront setting, making it a great spot to grab dessert during or after your elopement dinner. A slice of this pie paired with a stunning sunset? Unbeatable.

3. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Key Largo) – Rating: 8/10

If you’re driving down to Key West, make a pit stop at Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen in Key Largo. Their key lime pie is thick, creamy, and almost ice cream-like. The crust has just the right amount of crunch, and the flavor is rich and satisfying. This pie travels well, so if you’re eloping elsewhere in the Keys, it’s a great pick to bring along for your post-ceremony celebration.

4. Key Lime Pie Co. – Rating: 7/10

Key Lime Pie Co. offers a lighter, almost mousse-like version of this classic dessert. The filling is smooth and airy, while the crust adds a nice contrast. It’s easy to eat (and share!), though some might prefer a richer filling. Key Lime Pie Co. has whole pies available, making it a convenient choice if you want to replace a traditional wedding cake with something more local and unique.

This spot is great for Key West elopements since it’s conveniently located near Duval Street and they offer to go slices among many other variations of key lime pie treats like key lime bars, key lime pie in a cup, shakes, and mini pies. If you have a gluten allergy or sensitivity, they offer a gluten-free options as well.

5. Blue Heaven (Key West) – Rating: 6/10

Blue Heaven’s take on key lime pie is infamous for its sky-high meringue topping. While the pie itself is delicious, the meringue can be a bit overwhelming if you’re a key lime purist. If love quirky or unique things, the over-the-top look of Blue Heaven’s pie could be a fun and memorable dessert option. While my rating might ruffle some feathers, this key lime pie is perfect for couples the love a good meringue (it’s just not my thing).

Craving the perfect key lime pie for your elopement? Whether you want a classic slice, a boozy twist, or a dessert spread that’s totally unique, I’m here to help you find the sweetest way to celebrate. Let’s chat about your dream elopement (and the desserts that’ll make it even better)! Learn more about the experience, and let’s start planning. ?✨

Honorable Mentions: Key Lime-Inspired Treats

If pie isn’t your thing—or you want to shake things up—these key lime-inspired desserts and drinks are worth checking out:

• Key Lime Shake at Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen (Key Largo): Creamy, tangy, and refreshing, this is a fun, portable option for couples who are traveling by car to Key West. You can also get lunch here on your way down.

• Pearl Necklace at Better Than Sex (Key West): This dessert features key lime mousse with a graham cracker crust. It’s indulgent and elegant—a great pick for after a romantic dinner on Duval. Pro tip: make a reservation to this adult-only spot!

• Key Lime Coladas at Three Waters Resort & Marina (Islamorada): These boozy twists on the classic dessert are perfect for celebrating under the Florida sun. Every time we come down to Key West, it’s a must stop. Grab a cocktail and sip it on the dock or at the tiki bar.

• Key Lime Martini at The Roost (Key West): A sophisticated cocktail that brings key lime flavors into your drink menu. This place is my FAVORITE bar in Key West and an absolute must top if you’re into martinis.

Want to make your elopement even sweeter? Whether you’re dreaming of key lime pie, a creative dessert alternative, or a totally unique way to celebrate, I’ve got you covered. Let’s plan a day filled with adventure, love, and the best treats the Florida Keys have to offer. Learn more about how I can help, and let’s start crafting your perfect elopement! ?✨

Why Key Lime Pie Is the Ultimate Elopement Dessert

When you’re eloping, the rules go out the window. Forget towering wedding cakes and elaborate dessert spreads—your day should be all about the things you love. Here’s why key lime pie makes such a great elopement dessert:

1. It’s Unique: Most couples opt for traditional wedding cake, but choosing key lime pie ties your day to Florida’s signature flavors.

2. It’s Travel-Friendly: A whole pie or even a few slices are easy to transport, whether you’re eloping on the beach, a boat, or a tropical garden.

3. It’s Flexible: You can serve it as your main dessert, pair it with other treats, or even incorporate it into a key lime-inspired cocktail.

Ready to ditch the traditional wedding cake for something uniquely you? Key lime pie (or any Florida-inspired treat) is the perfect way to sweeten your elopement day. Whether you’re planning a beachfront picnic or a wild night on Duval, I’ll help you find the perfect dessert to match your vibe. Let’s start planning your dream elopement—sweet treats included! ?✨

Ready to Find the Perfect Dessert for Your Elopement?

Whether you’re a key lime pie enthusiast or just looking for a unique dessert to celebrate your Key West elopement, the Florida Keys have something for everyone. And as your Key West elopement photographer, I’m here to help you plan every detail—from finding the best key lime treats to capturing your greatest adventure together.

If you’re ready to start planning your stress-free, dessert-filled Florida elopement, let’s chat! Together, we’ll create a day that’s as unique, adventurous, and delicious as your love story.

So, which slice are you most excited to try? Let’s make your elopement unforgettable, one bite (and one photo) at a time.

Meet Your Key West Elopement Photographer